Why Do The BART Police Have Guns?

On Jan 1, an unarmed man was shot and killed while lying on his stomach on a BART train platform in Oakland. I don’t think I have anything substantial to add to what has already been said, except to ask this: why do the BART police carry guns?

It may surprise Americans to learn that even bona-fide police officers do not routinely carry guns in many countries, e.g. Britain. While I can certainly imagine public-transit situations that would require deadly force, other countries seem to have sorted out unarmed policing, even on the city streets.

47 thoughts on “Why Do The BART Police Have Guns?”

  1. I don’t know a huge amount about it, but my guess is that in Britain at least, strict gun control means that your average criminal probably doesn’t have a gun. Here in the states everyone has guns, so it makes sense for cops to be at least as armed as those they’re up against. As for why BART cops need guns — I have no clue.

  2. You know that old saying about “Guns don’t kill people”? Bollocks.

    What Heather said: stricter gun control means the chance of the adversary having a gun is greatly diminished. In England or Germany, cops may be facing a knife, but gun crime is virtually non-existent.

    Here in Norway, one policeman was killed in the last ten or more years, and that was in 2004 during an extremely violent bank robbery.

    Personally, with the exception of trips to the States, I have never seen a gun in my life that wasn’t in the hands of the military or the police.

  3. I live in the Monterey Bay area, about 80 miles south of SF. I go there a few times a year, but I, too, wonder why BART police have guns.

    I have no idea. I’m sure they would spout the typical reasons, but has there ever been a time where a shooting like this did not cause public outcry?

  4. Why do Bay Area Rapid Transit Police officers have guns? Are you kidding me? I often wonder why people have this idea that the BART PD is something less than any other bonafide law enforcement agency. BART PD officers are trained officers from the same academy with other officers in other agencies. Qualifications and training for BART police officers exceed the guidelines of the California Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST), which certifies all California peace officers. If anyone questions the need for firearms with our local transit police depts., then perhaps other agencies should surrender their weapons as well. Try telling the Port Authority to give up their guns. As far as the shooting of the individual at the BART station is concerned, this is truly a tragedy. I certainly have no idea why the officer pulled out his weapon and fired as he did. But there is no way that we could expect any law enforcement agency, no matter how small or insignificant anyone may find it, to not be armed when they deal with the kind of people they do on a daily basis. I commuted on BART for many years and know first hand of the kind of people that they deal with. Everyone just remember that the next time there is a violent crime occurs or is in progress on any transit property, as they do frequently, we will expect that officer to assist and defend a victim with deadly force if necessary.

  5. Thanks for your comment, Dan, and for clarifying the training that BART police receive. I certaintly don’t mean to impugn the training or dedication of the BART police.

    However — yes, I am asking the question of why cops carry guns. They don’t in many countries, you know (or at least do not always carry guns).

  6. Why do police in this country carry weapons? Because the US is one of the most violent nations in the world. Thanks to American TV, movies, games and news media, violence has become glorified to the point that much of our children have become numb to the sight of a gun and to death that people have used it for. Guns will be a part of American life as we know it for as long as we have a 2nd Amendment right to own them. The only problem is those individuals that mean to do harm with them, do so. Along with many of our freedoms here in the US, we will always have to live with the fact that guns are here, people will use them in violent crime and our Police forces will need guns to fight against guns. Gun bans, gun control and other forms of firearm laws will never rid our country of violent gun crime. The reasons are endless for violent crime and unless everyone has a gun to protect themselves from others with guns, our police will continue to have them. I’m sure by now, from what I have written, you can probably guess that I am a gun owner as well, but my guns are locked up and used to shoot cans and foul. I just wish people didn’t shoot other people.

  7. I have lived in India for the most of my life, and over there home invasion robberies involving firearms are lot more common than in US, even though gun control is lot more pervasive.

    Point being, that bad guys will ALWAYS find a way to own a gun as they don’t have to work within the framework of the law. It is the honest law abiding people who suffer.

    Also, I don’t know why guns are always blamed when a death occurs using firearm. When was the last time someone blamed a car, when a guy driving drunk ran over someone.

  8. Extractul de anghinare din componenta acestor comprimate ajuta la
    detoxifiera organismului si stimueaza functionare celulei
    hepatice reducand nivelul colesterolului din sange.Astfel 4 Femiina prosect in compozitia acestora se gaseste, acid folic 200 mcg, crom, 20 mcg,
    extract de guarana 100 mg, pulbere din suc dde anghinare
    100 mg, extract de urzica 50 mg, extract de ceai verde 50
    mg,excipienti. 4 Femina poate totodata sa cteasca libidoul, si sa elimine depozitele adipoase din organism,
    avant si actiune hepatoprotectoare. Contine extract de ceai verde ce
    are efect antioxidant si creste diureza, totodata eliminand
    si grasimile ddin corp.

  9. Good point. You could wish to read my latest short article as well.
    I do not wish to sound to pompous but I make sure you will discover it

  10. It’s the opposite of attractive and is quite repulsive.

    Adorable tattoo designs for girls are straightforward
    to arrive by. If you are a guy who is eager to create a good image on your first text message to a girl, here are some tips
    based on personal experience.

  11. The CFTC restructures its staff organization to facilitate the implementation of
    the Commodity Futures Modernization Act. The ideal auto transport company will assign you your
    own personal broker so he could become intimate using your particular situation and
    give you the deal best results to your situation. – Be ready to turn down non-profitable freight shipments.

  12. Los desenlaces significan que la terapia antirretroviral,
    ART, podría ser una herramienta de prevención útil, al igual que un buen tratamiento.

  13. You don??????t have to jailbreak the iPhone 4S to use R-Sim
    card, neither cutting of your iphone Sim card. It sits in your
    springboard just like there are like AppStore, Messaging, and Settings a default

  14. Niezwykłe spojrzenie na kwestię, każdy winien przeczytać
    oraz zapoznać się z motywem. test obciazenia
    glukoza cena, test obciążeniowy glukozą (Lester) obciazenia
    glukoza ciaza, test obciazenia glukoza normy

  15. File a lawsuit against the driver at fault if a fair negotiation is not possible.
    Apart from head related injuries, the attorney
    should be conversant with the proper knowledge to handle such
    cases. However, this method of looking for a good lawyer to
    represent you will not necessarily yield results especially if the people in your social and work circle should not have sufficient information about like

  16. W celu zwiększenia piękna rzęs stosowane mogą być zabiegi takie jak przedłużanie rzęs dzięki odżywkom do

    W celu podkreślenia uroku rzęs stosowane mogą być zabiegi takie jak przedłużanie rzęs dzięki odżywkom
    do rzęs.
    W ostatnim czasie doszło do rewolucji w dziedzinie przedłużania rzęs, gdyż
    istnieje szeroka gama produktów powstałych dla wzmocnienia rzęs.

    W minionym okresie doszło do odkrycia w dziedzinie przedłużania rzęs, ponieważ jest szeroka gama artykułów powstałych
    dla przedłużenia rzęs.

    REALASH to niekwestionowany nr 1 na świecie wśród
    odżywek do rzęs – przetestowany przez prawdziwe kobiety, przebadany przez dermatologów,
    polecany przez blogerki z całego świata.

    Odżywka do rzęs REALASH jest niekwestionowany nr 1 na świecie wśród odżywek do rzęs – przetestowany przez prawdziwe panie,
    przebadany przez dermatologów, rekomendowany przez internautki z całego świata.

  17. This is the perfect blog for anyone who really wants to understand
    this topic. You know a whole lot its almost tough to
    argue with you (not that I personally will need to…HaHa).
    You certainly put a fresh spin on a subject which has been written about for
    years. Great stuff, just great!

  18. The extraordinary beauty and mesmerizing shade of this precious gem draws the
    eye of individuals. Then cut up some Popsicle sticks for your framework.
    The main difference is more within the language.

  19. We had better use Msconfig or ask help from Windows optimization. Their payloads
    are spread out over the entire dump body in order to maintain the weight requirements of the federal bridge laws.

    Tiny video cameras are sometimes used to probe intricate
    pipes to pinpoint hidden leaks and problems.

  20. The entire effect of these rugs to a room should be considered when purchasing one.

    Their payloads are spread out over the entire dump body in order to maintain the weight requirements of the federal bridge laws.

    Experience the difference an experienced, reliable
    home theater setup company makes.

  21. As a homeowner, you will have maintenance and other related costs to keep your drain system
    running efficiently. But make sure that you consider the style your home is built
    with. Experience the difference an experienced, reliable home theater setup company makes.

  22. There is no need to purchase bottled water, which is expensive; you can store your own fresh
    drinking water for purposes of drinking in vertical
    storage tanks. Most of the time, when the topic is all about wastewater and sewage, the image people often get is that of bad smells
    and all that grime. In fact, there would be plenty of surplus water to irrigate the garden or sell to other consumers.

  23. As a homeowner, you will have maintenance and other related costs to keep your drain system running efficiently.
    It is necessary to wisely choose carpets to be placed in a room so that they can add color, style
    and warmth. These microbes will settle in the tank and digest the waste in the tank.

  24. Most people would like natural instead of synthetic vitamins.
    Good cholesterol or HDL helps your body rid itself of dietary cholesterol.
    Research strongly suggests that people with high levels of Omega-3 fatty acids in their blood experience positive brain qualities such as
    fewer signs of blood flow obstructions and fewer episodes
    of Dementia.

  25. Most of those supplements work by stopping the cause of baldness.
    Sometimes eating of bad calories result in making the dieter overweight which is really a matter of concern because it
    directly targets the working efficiency of its user.
    There are only 2 St Johns wort products that I know of, that have had been properly researched and the Flordis Remotiv is one of those.

  26. Every sports person whether he is a man or women needs
    sports supplements in order to avail best results. Its member companies manufacture popular national brands as well as the store brands marketed by major supermarkets, drug stores and discount chains.

    Do a simple search on Google or Amazon for a keyword
    like “dog supplements” and instantly you will get
    hundreds of thousands of results.

  27. There are far too many out there to just search through each day.
    You can even check out the customer reviews, and start availing more information, about those products.

    You may think that purchasing vegetables at a farmers market is healthier but you
    must be sure they use organic farming methods otherwise you may as well go to the local supermarket.

  28. Brain O Brain capsules tackle stress and produce high level of energy, the herbs used in the preparation of these capsules contain iron in high amount which enhances the capacity oxygen carrying of the blood by increasing the number of red blood cells.
    Excess consumption of zinc may cause bleeding stomach
    and severe abdominal pain. Research strongly suggests that people with high levels of
    Omega-3 fatty acids in their blood experience positive brain qualities such as fewer signs of blood
    flow obstructions and fewer episodes of Dementia.

  29. Most of the card dealers sell their cards online through websites that specialize in international calling cards.
    Not only do you want lots of people to visit your website but you also want your visitors to
    stay on your site and see if the deal is worthwhile by simply
    checking out your site. Once each item on the list of
    services is defined, select all of the individual items for that list, click the Home tab on the ribbon and choose Bullets
    again to turn the bulleted list formatting back on for that block of text as
    shown below:.

  30. In just a few days, you can have your shop up and running with Zen Cart.
    Small claims court cases are much cheaper than superior court cases for both the plaintiff
    (the person doing the suing) and the defendant (the person being
    sued) because the parties are not allowed to have any attorneys represent them and other rules that simplify
    the lawsuit process, making the whole thing much cheaper, faster, and easier.
    Once each item on the list of services is defined, select all of the individual items for that
    list, click the Home tab on the ribbon and choose Bullets
    again to turn the bulleted list formatting back on for that
    block of text as shown below:.

  31. The website will also serve as a portal for all things convention related, from a countdown clock to information on logistics, credentials,
    media walkthroughs and housing. The website navigation should
    cater to both the users and the search engine bots. The website templates are well-equipped with HTML coding which could result into better looking websites in minor budget also.

  32. Many small companies prefer to hire SEO specialists as consultants rather than full time employees, unless they have a certain amount of websites that need to be continuously maintained and
    optimized. So what are you going to put in their search
    box is “website optimization tips”. Depending on how how much time you have you can do
    this about once per week. This mode of advertisement was faster
    than the earlier ones and reached more people but it had its own limitations.

  33. I’m amazed, I must say. Rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both equally educative and interesting, and without a doubt, you’ve hit the nail on the head.
    The issue is something that too few folks are speaking intelligently about.
    Now i’m very happy I came across this during my hunt for something regarding this.

  34. Vortex Crossfire and Diamondback are their entry level binoculars and are actually great quality and definitely
    excellent value for money.

  35. Although Yahoo isn’t the biggest, or the highest ranking search engine on the internet, it is still one of the most essential, and if you want use search engine optimization and promotion as a
    main technique in your marketing arsenal, you unquestionably need to get listed here.
    When Page – Rank was patented the patent was assigned to Stanford
    University. While effective SEO needn’t be difficult,
    it does take work. Eventbrite is an online party-planning tool with KISS (Keep It Simple Stupid) design so it is usually a top rated choice among event planners (organizers).

  36. Gone are the days of one way marketing or merely just posting
    comments about your site or other related topics. Thirdly, the search engines need legit companies to do site optimization. But in general here are the services
    that an online business owner should expect from SEO
    experts and other agencies and consultants:. Further the sites whose ranking using the search engines is good will attract potential clients, which results to mores sales.

  37. Cyberspace policies. Let’s face it. The internet showed up some years earlier, and it’s right here to
    stay. Who would have thought of 10 years ago how far we have come now?

    There was a time when talking with a friend face-to-face in a country halfway throughout the world was unheard of.
    Now, we have videophones and web cams that make this possible.
    Our modern-day lives have progressed to move the virtual.
    Gone are the pen and paper days, when possessing a business suggested documents to be processed and submitted manually, difficult copies of business authorizations needed to exist and you
    needed to have actual workplace space to be able to work.
    Nowadays, we can start an online company without the inconvenience of standing in line or pulling filing cabinets open.
    There is really little that is genuinely complimentary and this
    is extremely true with webhosting business. You enter the door cheaply however what
    takes place later? Your bandwidth is too limited;
    you experience issues and cannot get support.

    Your website decreases. What is that worth? Absence of proper support, which is
    costly, is one way they offset the lower rate at the start.

    So then exactly what’s the issue? The issue is that you such as so many others new to Online marketing, are merely failing to understand the value of Search
    Engine Optimization. Sure there are countless potential new clients or
    customers out there online. But at the exact same time you have actually failed to sufficiently take into account level of competitors you’re up against.

    I do not mean to pick on this particular business, which is why I’m not discussing them by name
    or offering you enough details to make an informed guess.
    Since this problem affects business and companies of all shapes and sizes, that’s.
    I’ve seen numerous instances when companies leaped out with a
    powerful air travel of marketing messages, only to discover that the folks who really had to provide on those
    messages just weren’t prepared to handle the responses.

    Mobile phone have ended up being very attractive as advertising tools also;
    a recent Harris survey reports that the mobile phone use
    is increasing while the conventional landline telephone is fast losing clients.
    The reality is 20 % of the grownups in the US do
    not have a landline. The same percentage now utilize only mobile phone,
    and the number is growing very quick. Additionally, while mobile phone
    amongst the more youthful generation have actually been widely reported, they are likewise becoming popular amongst older populations too.
    For the under 30 crowd, practically 40 % of them make use of absolutely nothing but a cell
    phone or the internet for communication. This indicates that over 80
    % of your clients own a mobile phone and you can reach them any time
    24/7 in the house, at the workplace or on the road; all you
    need is an isp and a computer system.
    Finally the third way you can get paid and make cash
    through affiliate programs is when you are paid
    per sale or lead. This is the payment scheme
    with the greatest dollar value. You just make if your
    visitors click through the banner on your internet marketing site and either purchase an item or sign up for a
    Anticipating instantaneous results with Search Engine Optimization will lead you to making a lot of unnecessary errors.
    Patience is a should for SEO. You will be rewarded with long term traffic.
    Are you prepared to hit the first page for keywords that get countless
    searches per month? You must be prepared to construct links, create distinct content and put in the time to have everything in place, then you can simply forget getting ranked
    for any keyword.
    If you scan this rapidly, you will certainly understand the scenario the author is trying to communicate however there are issues in the method this paragraph
    is written and, if you read the entire page, you
    will certainly find issues with the continuity of the story.
    The very first issue is that, due to bad building, this paragraph does not in fact make sense.
    For instance, one sentence checks out “When there was a knock at the door.” A comma instead of a stop after “TV” would assist a bit to
    making good sense but it would still be an awkward sentence.
    Likewise, I understand how a crowd scatters but how does
    one individual manage “scattering” on his own? He
    more than likely implied “rushing” however the reader should not need to work
    to figure out definition, its part of the writer’s job
    to make the definition clear.

  38. You see for a very long time there has been an on going
    struggle and a hotly contested fight between exactly what I
    call tattoo traditionalists and the more recent tattoo
    artists. This is truly a reflection or similar to the age old power struggle
    that teenagers frequently go through as they try to form their own identity and separate themselves from their moms and dads.

    That’s the first thing. Read the rules. Various forums approach how you show links differently or perhaps exactly what you can discuss, so don’t blow it
    on your first or 2nd check out.

    Keyword research study is an important step in any type
    of search engine marketing. Basically, with the wrong list of
    keywords, no matter how great you are ranking, you will not make any money.
    Without targeted traffic you will not make any sales. Your focus
    ought to be on keywords that are popular amongst searchers.
    Since you won’t win the race, with the best keywords you are off to a running beginning; with the
    wrong keywords you may as well start over. Once you have found some high volume keywords you can begin preparing
    your site structure and motifs. There are a variety of totally free keyword tools that you can make use of to generate appropriate keywords for your website.

    The problem does not start with choosing the right program or guide,
    however instead starts with going from one money making method to another.

    It is very important to establish your plan with the right marketing methods
    and stick with them. If you do not stick to your strategy, you will never ever find out
    if it works or not.
    Banner advertising – A lot of individuals think that banner marketing
    is going away since no one wish to be sold to. Nobody wish to see “banner” of individuals trying
    to sell them something. You require to offer something real, genuine and make your
    ad mix into the rest of the material of the advertising.
    You can acquire actually cheap banner all the method to actually pricey banners.

    The other thing is do not be available in internet marketing gang busters
    !! Do not try to show yourself and get too ecstatic about revealing everyone your knowledge and so on. Rest and build.
    Build your knowledge in addition to your reputation.
    Consider that: every week, that chain invested a fortune to
    draw clients to its doors, and afterwards proceeded to drive a number of those consumers
    away. All because advertising and logistics were unable to communicate.

    Once you understand everything about them, you can now start
    to design a strategy of action to get a step up on them.
    You understand their negatives and pluses. Whether
    you advertise on our site, in radio, print or television, you
    can now use that information in your advertising campaign.

    1% Marketing & Web Design Champaign
    1702 Hedge Rd.
    Champaign, Illinois 61821
    (217) 383-0900

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.